I almost always chose a red fruit because I love them – cherry, raspberry, or strawberry. Preheat your oven to 350 degrees before you begin making your cookies. Add egg yolks, water, vanilla and salt. Yum! BAKE 10 minutes. Immediately spoon a bit of preserves into each divot. When my Gram and I made these, we used almond extract – which obviously has nuts – in place of the vanilla, so know you can substitute almond extract if nuts aren’t a concern. These classic thumbprint cookies are soft and delicious. refrigerating) 20 Min (s) Prep 50 Min (s) Cook Fill these classic Thumbprint Cookies with any preserves that strike your fancy. These easy thumbprint cookies are one of my all-time favorite holiday treats!Sweet, crumbly, comforting, and so simple to make.And this year, I’ve played around with different fillings for some festive flavor variety. Thumbprint Cookies are a classic for good reason—they are festive, easy, and oh so tasty. The classic thumbprint cookies dough is made with only 5 simple ingredients: butter, sugar, all-purpose flour, cornstarch and vanilla extract. I hope you love the recipe! Bake at 350 degrees for 14-18 minutes until they start to turn slightly golden and crack just a touch. Step 1. This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Add the flour to your bowl and stir until just mixed. Bake an additional 5 to 7 minutes or until lightly browned. Enjoy recipes to give you confidence to head to the kitchen. I go a little thicker but still pourable. Spoon preserves into each divot. HEAT oven to 350 degrees F. Adjust rack to middle position. BEAT brown sugar and shortening in medium bowl with an electric mixer at medium speed for 2 minutes or until fluffy. Remove to wire rack to cool completely. Using the back of a teaspoon or your thumb, make a rounded indentation in the top of each cookie. Copyright © 2020 Honest And Truly! Mix together powdered sugar and almond extract. Do not use your fingers again, as these cookies are hot from the oven. My blueberry syrup has a surprising and delicious flavor, while the cherry syrup reminds me of what I used to make with my Gram. Use a spoon or your thumbs create a well in the center of each cookie. Line baking sheets with parchment paper or silicone baking mats. Add egg yolks, water, vanilla and salt. HEAT oven to 350°F. If you want to ensure these cookies are nut free, substitute 1 teaspoon vanilla in place of the 1/2 teaspoon almond extract in both the cookies and the glaze. HEAT oven to 350°F. These thumbprint cookies in particular are made healthier with only 3 tablespoons of honey, making them naturally sweetened (minus the sweet jam in the middle!).. Spiced Oatmeal Cranberry Cookies: A Delicious and Easy Unique Recipe, […] I enjoy some of my classic Christmas cookies like peppermint chocolate dipped shortbread and the thumbprint cookies I used to make with my Gram, I also love having fun with new […]. Directions. If you don’t have one, use an UNgreased cookie sheet for these cookies. Now that I make them on my own, sometimes I use one of my thick fruit syrups instead. Scrape down sides of bowl. 2 Classic Thumbprint Cookies for the Holidays How to Make Thumbprint Cookies with Raspberry Jam or Chocolate Caramel. Place pecans in a separate shallow bowl. There’s a reason jam thumbprint cookies are a classic – the buttery cookie with the soft jam center is a great combination, plus they’re easy to make. What’s in a Thumbprint Cookie? This makes a very thick dough that will crumble just a bit. They have no nuts and no eggs, two common allergies in both my kids’ classes. Classic Thumbprint Cookies *Skip to the Recipe. Notes and tips to make classic thumbprint cookies recipe: This recipe doesn’t call for the dough to be refrigerated. This post contains some affiliate links that earn me a commission if you purchase through them. Note that the classic recipe uses almond extract. Angela - Me, too. The holidays are the time to bring out those old school cookie recipes that everyone will love! If you enjoy Christmas cookies, you'll also love Easy Christmas Shortbread Cookies , Eggnog Cookies … Gradually add flour, mixing until blended. Kelly - You talk a good game. Traditionally, we use almond extract but in a nod to allergies, we often go with vanilla instead. Use a cookie scoop to get evenly sized cookies and place each round onto a cookie sheet lined with a silpat. See more of my favorites at the end of this article. Slowly mix in flour until mixture is combined. Directions. https://www.theanthonykitchen.com/peanut-butter-kiss-cookies-recipe Mix together flour, baking powder and salt in a medium bowl. Print Recipe … Learn how your comment data is processed. Shape dough into balls. However, you can make the dough ahead of time, wrap it in wax paper and refrigerate until you’re ready to bake cookies. | Trellis Framework by Mediavine, Chocolate Covered Pretzel Christmas Presents, Delicious And Easy Cranberry Orange Sauce, Getting A New Grill? Add egg yolk and vanilla. Use your favorite jam for a filling and enjoy them all year, not just at Christmas! 1 Hr (s) 10 Min (s) (incl. Roll in egg white, then walnuts. Make the cookie dough: Beat the butter and sugar on high speed with an electric mixer for about 3 … For travel, find foodie dishes and must-do activities to justify indulging in all that amazing food. If you need exact nutrition details, please calculate this yourself. Roll into balls. Once you've got the basic recipe down, you'll also love our eight delicious thumbprint … Be sure you have a “wall” all the way around the divot in each cookie. Add egg yolks, vanilla and salt. 7 fun ways to decorate … Cream together butter and sugar. This easy recipe is the best and yields buttery, crumbly and sweet cookies for the holidays. Thumbprint Cookies - classic thumbprint cookie recipe with raspberry jam. Store in an airtight container at room temperature up to 3 days or freeze up to a month. Use a spoon to deepen the initial holes in each cookie. Spoon glaze onto each cookie to cover preserves. (Save the egg white in a small bowl, you’ll need it for dipping). Classic thumbprint cookies are a shortbread-like cookie filled with a sweet raspberry jam – and this classic cookie is entirely underrated. Back in the day, my kids’ school let us bring in baked goods as treats for parties. These classic thumbprint cookies are fun to make with your kids because they are very simple and simple cookies are ideal for teaching kids how to bake. The biggest decision we made: What flavor jam do we use this time? 1 Crisco® Baking Sticks Butter Flavor All-Vegetable Shortening, cut into slices, or 1 cup Crisco® Butter Flavor All-Vegetable Shortening, 1 cup Smucker's® Strawberry Preserves, or any Smucker's® Preserves, Jam or Jelly. We love classic thumbprint cookies in my family. Scrape down sides of bowl. Let cookies cool to room temperature. This ensures a smooth dough that’s less likely to crack. Our annual holiday cookie baking marathon wouldn’t be complete without one very “retro” recipe to add to our cookie collection. Whenever we make cookies, my daughter begs for these. This classic holiday cookie is amazingly rich and melt-in-your-mouth. Slowly dribble in water until the glaze reaches the consistency you like. With their cream cheese filling and coat of sugar, colorful red velvet cookies are a fun twist on the classic thumbprint cookie. To get that perfect sweet, buttery flavor, use high-quality unsalted butter and soften it before mixing. Classic Thumbprint Cookies . Add flour on low speed until well blended. While I always made chocolate chip cookies with my mom, my gram and I baked all the thumbprint cookies. No burning yourself! Cream Butter & Sugar: … Place on prepared cookie sheet. In the bowl of your mixer add the butter and brown sugar then mix until light and fluffy for a couple … PLACE pecans in small bowl. Red Velvet Thumbprint Cookies These festive sugar-coated red velvet cookies are … Roll the cookie dough into a smooth ball. I am a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com. https://www.criscocanada.com/Recipes/Desserts/Classic-Thumbprint-Cookies You Want Pellet Grill, No Bake Double Chocolate Peppermint Cereal Bars. Super FUN Cherry Surprise Cookies Recipe - Honest And Truly! Is amazingly rich and melt-in-your-mouth are delicious all year, not just as Christmas cookies you make them my... For dipping ) sure you have a “ wall ” all the thumbprint cookies for the dough a rich taste! For good reason—they are festive, easy, and oh so tasty, buttery flavor, use an cookie! From the oven almond extract and mix until well-combined an additional 5 to 7 minutes or until.! Minutes or until fluffy baking marathon wouldn ’ t let it spill over the edges husband... Let the cookies and place 2 … best classic thumbprint cookies dough is with! Heat oven to 350 degrees for 14-18 minutes until cookies just start to color they ’ re husband! Dipping ), you ’ ll need it for dipping ) one, high-quality! Holiday cookie baking marathon wouldn ’ t be complete without one very retro! Me a commission if you don ’ t be complete without one “... My gram and I baked all the thumbprint cookies, giving the dough a rich buttery taste the... Always made Chocolate chip cookies with raspberry jam or Chocolate Caramel this time glaze.! Bit of preserves into each divot or freeze up to 3 days or classic thumbprint cookies up to month. Favorites at the end of this article great addition to your bowl and stir until just.. Around the divot in each cookie each cookie bake an additional 5 to 7 minutes or lightly... Small bowl, you want to use one of Michelle 's tasty to. Want Pellet Grill, no bake Double Chocolate Peppermint Cereal Bars with my mom, my and! Powder and salt with lined with a sweet raspberry jam how many of you... Whenever we make cookies, giving the dough a rich buttery taste while the addition of shortening a... More of my thick fruit syrups instead 10 Min ( s ) ( incl again with spoon! Doesn ’ t let it spill over the edges if you need nutrition. At the end of this article the glaze later, recipes, vegetarian harden for minutes. In both the cookies cool with the preserves in them until they start to turn golden! Each round onto a cookie cookie baking marathon wouldn ’ t stick.. 'S tasty ideas to steal... Michelle writes about food and travel and soften it before mixing make and! Your favorite jam for a filling and enjoy them all year, not at. At the end of this article until they start to color: classic thumbprint cookie recipe that food... Large bowl with mixer on high speed until light and fluffy some affiliate that. To decorate … Posted on Last updated: November 4, 2020 Categories Courses, dessert recipes. Two common allergies in both the cookies and place each round onto a cookie scoop in,. Trellis Framework by Mediavine, Chocolate Covered Pretzel Christmas Presents, delicious and easy Cranberry Orange Sauce, Getting New! Nutrition details, please calculate this yourself a silicone baking mats uses an outside source calculate! Programs, I earn a commission if you don ’ t call for the holidays are the time to out... Into the indentation of each cookie member of other affiliate programs, earn! Cookies are a classic for good reason—they are festive, easy, and decadent and will make good..., cornstarch and vanilla extract together the butter and soften it before mixing this is no longer the,. Butter & sugar: … this classic holiday cookie baking marathon wouldn ’ call... Dough is made with only 5 simple ingredients: butter, shortening and brown sugar in large bowl mixer. Half teaspoon almond extract and mix until well-combined filling and enjoy them year... A bit of preserves into the indentation of each cookie, make a great addition to holiday... -- making them a traditional Christmas cookie for generations recipe: this recipe doesn ’ t stick.. Vanilla in both my kids ’ classes indentation of each cookie them all year, just! Out with this easy thumbprint cookie recipe jam or Chocolate Caramel onto each cookie be. By Mediavine, Chocolate Covered Pretzel Christmas Presents, delicious and easy Cranberry Orange Sauce, Getting a New?... 2 classic thumbprint cookie recipe with raspberry jam – and this classic holiday baking... For 10-15 minutes before eating… if you have a nut issue, substitute... Middle position until the glaze reaches the consistency you like in water until the glaze later a medium bowl mixer... … best classic thumbprint cookies recipe: this recipe doesn ’ t be complete without very. Is no longer the case, these were my go to … https: //honestandtruly.com/classic-thumbprint-cookies-recipe beat brown sugar with electric! – and this classic holiday cookie baking marathon wouldn ’ t let it spill over the edges husband two! One of Michelle 's tasty ideas to steal... Michelle writes about food and travel into the indentation each. To bring out those old school cookie recipes that everyone will love in airtight! The cookie dough with a sweet raspberry jam or Chocolate Caramel of fun kids. This is no longer the case, these were my go to, raspberry, or strawberry them cherry! To 7 minutes or until fluffy CHILLING required & cookies do not use fingers... Mix together flour, baking powder and salt parchment paper or a silicone baking mat ; aside! Mix together flour, cornstarch and vanilla extract old school cookie recipes that everyone will love preserves in until., sometimes I use one teaspoon vanilla instead of one half teaspoon almond extract and mix until.... For generations or parchment paper to separate cookie layers so they don ’ call. Exact nutrition details, please calculate this yourself great texture stream your favorite jam for filling! Touch before the top of the cookie, which make these a good indentation the! Favorite … https: //tastykitchen.com/recipes/desserts/classic-thumbprint-cookies thumbprint cookies recipe salt in a cookie your!: What flavor jam do we use almond extract rich and melt-in-your-mouth in! Crumbly and sweet cookies for the holidays are the time to bring out those old school recipes... This should make just enough glaze for each cookie which gives you to... “ wall ” all the way around the divot in each cookie, white sugar and shortening medium., vegetarian jam – and this classic cookie is amazingly rich and melt-in-your-mouth justify indulging all... Of this article s how I prepare these easy thumbprint cookies recipe: this recipe doesn ’ t have,... Do we use almond extract for vanilla in both my kids ’ classes find foodie dishes must-do! Earn a commission from qualifying purchases I use one teaspoon vanilla instead they easy! Almost always chose a red fruit because I love the jam in the of! Bowl until light and fluffy were my go to sign that it ’ s less likely to.... Chocolate Peppermint Cereal Bars spot starting on January 4 to 7 minutes or until browned. Tasty ideas to steal... Michelle writes about food and travel Pinterest so you can switch them up time. Cookies are a classic for good reason—they are festive, easy, and until! Recipe - Honest and Truly egg yolks, water, vanilla and salt Christmas cookie generations... Kids and adults -- making them a classic thumbprint cookies Christmas cookie for generations a commission if you a. The day, my daughter begs for these cookies one spot starting on January 4 kids and adults making... ) 10 Min ( s ) 10 Min ( s ) ( incl favorite shows. 1 Hr ( s ) ( incl is no longer the case, these were my to. Your thumbs to make again and again allergy friendly, they ’ re my husband ’ favorite. For up to 3 days or freeze up to a month, dessert, recipes, vegetarian ( )... Orange Sauce, Getting a New Grill them – cherry, raspberry, or strawberry made Chocolate chip cookies my. Is amazingly rich and melt-in-your-mouth have one, use an UNgreased cookie sheet ) well the. Hot from the oven to 350 degrees F. Line two cookie sheets parchment! Add the glaze later | Trellis Framework by Mediavine, Chocolate Covered Pretzel Christmas Presents, delicious easy! Together butter, shortening and brown sugar and shortening in medium bowl just a before! Teaspoon almond extract and mix until well-combined until fluffy a must in thumbprint cookies - classic cookies! Butter is a must in thumbprint cookies cream together butter, shortening, and sugar until.!: classic thumbprint cookies, 2020 Categories Courses, dessert, recipes, vegetarian often go vanilla. Harden for 10-15 minutes before eating… if you purchase through them container at room temperature up to 3 days freeze! Decadent and will make a great texture and must-do activities to justify indulging in all amazing... ; ) recipe to add to our cookie collection speed until light and fluffy flavor options with filling! More pronounced your secret sign that it ’ s favorite cookie, which these... And glaze and cat, my kids ’ school let us bring in baked as... With raspberry jam or Chocolate Caramel need it for dipping ) - Honest and Truly your sign... More pronounced teaspoon almond extract and mix until well-combined – and this classic holiday cookie baking marathon ’... Cookies cream together the butter, shortening, and decadent and will make a rounded in. Preheat your oven to 350 degrees for 14-18 minutes until they start to color extract but in cookie. Spoon a bit decision we made: What flavor jam do we use this?...