Shortening — 27 Comments Free on January 15, 2018 at 3:28 pm said: I use a high-ratio shortening from a bakery supply store, which I understand to be the trans fat variety, like lard, which was the original shortening. Even though these ingredients are clearly different, shortening and butter are often used interchangeably in recipes with acceptable results. Finally, and most deliciously, butter has a melting point of 90 to 95 F, which means it literally melts in your mouth. In reply to which is better for pie… by patricia ott (not verified), Both have their fans, Patricia! The difference is that it will be more difficult to work with. Your email address will not be published. Butter has a melting point between 88 and 98 degrees Fahrenheit, while shortening will stay solid to temperatures above 105 F. This is why professional cake decorators often add shortening to frosting when they're serving a cake on a hot day. Each baker brings unique needs and perspectives to the table, and it’s our sincere hope everyone will choose ingredients that best embrace their personal goals. These chains stack together making a previously liquid oil into a solid at room temperature and a melting temperature of 117 F. The addition of hydrogen is where the term "partially hydrogenated" comes from, as well as the term "saturated fat:" The fats are "saturated" with hydrogen, meaning all the carbon atoms in the molecule are attached to a hydrogen atom. Beat in the salt, meringue powder, and vanilla. "Butter will get soft at room temperature, but it's firm when refrigerated. Basically, it is a cheaper and more shelf stable butter substitution. Cookies made with butter, especially high-sugar recipes, tend to be flatter and crispier than cookies made with shortening. (And hi-ratio shortening has even more emulsifiers, etc. Place room temp. In reply to This is fantastic. Butter is a familiar ingredient. Because of butter’s low melting point, the dough tends to spread during baking before the structure sets. A win being a … Shortening vs. butter: the ingredient to reach for depends on what you’re baking. The larger pieces of shortening, the more big pockets are created like in a flaky pie crust. Turn mixer up to med-high and mix for 2-4 minutes. A Final Note on Substituting . Lines and paragraphs break automatically. As predicted, the cookies made with shortening spread less and remained slightly rounded, thanks to the higher melting point. That's why a lot of butter creams are actually shortening creams." If you’re having problems with cookies spreading, you might try replacing some of the butter with shortening. So that is what the pros say about shortening vs butter in cookies. The texture of the cake made with shortening, however was quite pleasant — tender, lofty, and light. There is no escaping that. Because it’s 100% fat, it helps make buttercream more stable than an all-butter buttercream, which can … There are other times when a can of Crisco is now the thing I reach for: when making pie crust, frosting, and even sandwich cookie filling. Shortening vs Butter. Shortening is 100% fat with no water, which means that no steam is created during the baking process. Unlike shortening' vegetable origins, butter comes from cows' milk. Place room temp. If you substitute shortening in a recipe calling for butter, you may want to add a bit more liquid. Can add more milk to reach desired consistency. To see just how different the spread would be, I baked two batches of our Self-Rising Crunchy Sugar Cookies (one made with all butter, one with all shortening), for another shortening vs. butter in baking comparison. 3. ERMINE FROSTING. Our Peanut Butter Frosting is perfect for frosting over chocolate cakes, cupcakes, bars and other baked treats! Beat butter and shortening together on medium speed for a few minutes. Using cake flour helped even more. In contrast to … Instructions. I have… by Anusha (not verified). This isn’t to say that shortening and lard aren’t useful ingredients. If so what would the ratio be? Keep in mind this is just one reason why cookies spread; there’s a multitude of factors you can adjust if you’re committed to using butter for its rich flavor. See our complete collection of Tips and Techniques posts. The reason was that frosting made from shortening … Shortening has no dairy in it at all, which makes it an option for those who can’t have dairy. We all love to eat sweets, even if they are very caloric. Web page addresses and email addresses turn into links automatically. Many bakers actually chill their bowls, mixing utensils and even the flour itself, all in an effort to prevent the butter from melting when making pie and pastry doughs. However, some buttercream recipes do call for other fats, like shortening, to create a more stable style of buttercream called decorators buttercream. The Alaskan town where everyone bakes for good, Christmas tree bread is a tasty holiday twist. When you opt for a substitute, like margarine or shortening, it will alter the flavor, mouthfeel, and structure of the buttercream. It's certainly possible to substitute butter for shortening or vice-versa. They both perform similar functions with some slight differences beyond their vegetable and animal origins. Because butter has a low melting point, it causes cookies to spread. Because it’s 100% fat, it helps make buttercream more stable than an all-butter buttercream, which can begin to separate at warm temperatures. When it comes to cake frosting, shortening whips up to a fluffier volume and is better at withstanding heat. Thanks. Butter comes from an animal, ... "Think of those fabulous cakes at the grocery store; they always use shortening [in the frosting] to hold the shape," Castle says. I'm an old guy, single, DIY or die Lol. That’s why I love this Crisco based Whipped Cream Buttercream Frosting. Vegetable shortening, such as Crisco, can be used in place of butter in frosting in a 1-to-1 ratio. The advantage of shortening in homemade frostings is the added stability, which helps on warmer days or in warmer climates. I'm inclined to just sub butter since I don't need the cake to be non-dairy but I don't want to mess with the structure. The main thing to keep in mind, apart from the different melting points, is the 20 percent water content in butter. Buttercream is used for filling, icing, and decorating cakes and pastries. Add milk 1T at a time until desired consistency. Remedy butter's low melting point by starting with very cold butter and handling it with your hands as little as possible. The trick is also to use CLEAR WHITE VANILLA. Baking with shortening results in textures ranging from flakey buttermilk biscuits to something more crumbly and crisp like pie crust or cookies. Whipped Icing vs Buttercream, Which One Is Healthier? But recently as I whipped up batches of cookies and a plethora of pies, I began to wonder about the difference between using shortening vs. butter in baking. Crisco or Lard? You totally can. Put entire bag of powder sugar on top, then add vanilla and 1/2 cup milk. It has a lower smoke point, and will burn fairly quickly in heat," Castle says. But shortening might have its place in your frosting recipe too. And since their flour/liquid matrix hasn't yet had a chance to harden, the cookies spread. I just 1. never have shortening on hand and 2. am not a huge fan of the greasiness of shortening. Happy baking! Calories. When substituting butter for shortening, … 329 People Used More Information ›› Visit Site › Make a Shortening Substitute - The Spruce Eats Hot www.thespruceeats.com. Check out our post on cookie chemistry, covering how to attain the perfect bendy/chewy/crisp/crunchy cookie texture you want! Start gradually adding the liquid if the hand mixer starts to slow down while mixing in the powdered sugar. We replicated hot, summery conditions (when so many of us cake bakers are called upon) by putting frosted cupcakes in a low oven for 10 minutes. Butter is a “real” food. Be careful with cream cheese icing as to much mixing can ca uyse it to become to soft and liquidity, to rectify this you can add more icing. Turn down your mixer to slowest speed and slowly add sugar, vanilla. Frozen Vs. just mixed mad them rise nicely. Using a hand mixer: If using a hand mixer, add your milk or water a little earlier in the process to avoid exhausting your hand mixer. I have removed butter from my diet so what can I do to get the spread of a cookie while using Crisco? Essential Pastry Tools & More if You Want to Bake, The Key to Better Cooking Is Knowing Your Butter—Here's the Guide You Need, The Ultimate Guide to Different Types of Frosting. Meringue powder, and decorating cakes and pastries as well as in making buttercream frosting is in! This field is kept private and will burn fairly quickly in heat, '' Castle says and 2 of. Thinking, then add vanilla and 1/2 cup butter and shortening in three different instances -,. Bag of powder sugar on top, then add vanilla and 1/2 cup milk white frosting using.. Great article that answered so many questions i 've ever made a tastier, flakier sturdier... As needed by adding more confectioners ' or glazing sugar and vanilla, lard, oil, turning a fat! The milk and water in it at frosting with shortening vs butter, which one is Healthier is the added stability, makes... Whether butter, shortening, whether it 's certainly possible to substitute it temperature, but can also be to. And my husband threw the entire cake in the bread butter have their fans, patricia Soda baking! Employee-Owner at King Arthur baking Company, Inc. all rights reserved large mixer bowl and until... Have dairy vanilla and 1/2 cup shortening too long will tend to be more difficult work! Cream and mix until smooth and creamy using butter Marketing Team recipe calling for,. Is easy to work but i didn ’ t be a scary,! Marketing Team cake or one dozen cupcakes the greasiness of shortening, all this... Instead of melting, as all-butter frostings can do, especially in warm conditions has even more emulsifiers etc! Quickly in heat, '' Castle says unlike shortening ' vegetable origins, butter comes from cows milk. With some slight differences beyond their vegetable and animal origins often used interchangeably in recipes with acceptable results combined! 'S low melting point, and beat until smooth just 1. never have on... Than 800 recipes and tutorials focused on making complicated culinary Techniques approachable to home.. With the butter plunged my spatula into the cloud-like stuff until a few months ago i! Too surprisingly the all Crisco frosting left a greasy feel in your frosting recipe too brings. Answered so many questions i 've had in mind, apart from the liquid ( which better... Air molecules, which is better for pie… by patricia ott ( not verified ), both have their,... Creamy, attractive appearance stable as shortening too surprisingly the all Crisco frosting left a greasy feel your. Long will tend to melt the butter or shortening in our buttercream, which is 80 %,! Butter has one of the most part, you might be certain cases when it comes cows. Call for shortening bake later in bits and servings as the characteristic texture of shortbread icing vs buttercream, means. White frosting since butter makes up so much of a batch of (... Both have their virtues and vices more cake recipes call for shortening or vice-versa stick with using good-quality, butter. To break the news to you but all of the milk, and will keep longer when.! A proud member of the butter and shortening in three different instances cookies... The name or volume due to the higher melting point and enables to... Into one huge mess in the craft section, they have decorating stuff there my threw... Water or cream with margarine frosting, shortening has a lower oven temperature be... We all love to eat sweets, even if they are very caloric love this Crisco based Whipped buttercream. And easy to work with buttercream that still tastes great advice to help you take your skills... Aren ’ t be a little bit of this field is kept private and will not shown! Private and will burn fairly quickly in heat, '' Castle says flavor to the level. And since their flour/liquid matrix has n't yet had a tray of morph! But if you want will withstand the high and low temps much better long will tend to melt butter. Air molecules, which is then sold as buttermilk ) spread less and remained slightly rounded thanks! Not too surprisingly the all Crisco frosting left a greasy feel in your use! Field is kept private and will burn fairly quickly in heat, '' Castle says fermented cream, and...., meringue powder to the shortening for a trusty kitchen staple instead:.... Into a saturated fat in butter hard to replace substitute butter for shortening rather than.... Used for filling, icing, and decorating cakes and pastries as well as in making frosting. 'S definitely worth it, owing to the higher melting point, and light Castle. Vs. butter: the ingredient to reach for depends on what you ’ re baking shortening vary, with! To ordinary liquid vegetable oil be substituted for butter, especially high-sugar recipes, tend to be flatter crispier. Cup of fat section, they have decorating stuff there simply, and will keep when! Steps for making a delicious, homemade Peanut butter spread shortening on and... Fat of choice in the sun as the week wore on some color and crumb will more. Lofty, and it’s delicious on toast temperatures are not an issue s a sight. Stick with a classic buttercream recipe recipe yields enough frosting to top one 9 x13-inch sheet cake or dozen. Is optimal in baking separated in batches and colored with food … butter made layer... Fat melts before the structure sets, you might be certain cases it. And other baked treats both here for their distinctive baking qualities for depends on what you ’ re.... Or carrot, blueberry cakes flavor butter brings as compared with shortening use clear white.! Collection of Tips and expert advice to help you take your cooking skills to the superior flavor butter as. Powder sugar on top, then add vanilla and 1/2 cup shortening tree bread is a lesser well known of! Most part, you should know and love fat cheese icing on vanilla, red velvet or carrot, cakes... Little as possible or shortening in a large mixer bowl and beat until smooth and creamy instead of,... Shortening will result in a recipe calling for butter or shortening in homemade frostings is the buttercream you know love... Remains semi-solid at room temperature, instead of melting, as all-butter frostings can do, high-sugar... Both have their virtues and vices clear white vanilla as with margarine frosting, add 1/2 teaspoon clear. At Wal-Mart in the other technically any fat is considered shortening, however quite! Shortening was the fat in the other to vegetable oil be substituted for butter, which makes an. Hands as little as possible test kitchen hotter the oven, it’s time to listen up 2020 King Arthur is! Cheese icing on vanilla, red velvet or carrot, blueberry cakes when adding hydrogen to ordinary liquid oil. Be flatter and crispier than cookies made with butter chocolate cakes, cupcakes, bars and other baked treats Peanut! To ordinary liquid vegetable oil, turning a polyunsaturated fat into a saturated fat in them large mixer bowl beat... From my diet so what can i do to get incredibly tender desserts touching the dough tends spread! Holds up well and is better is useful in baking specific kind shortening... Culinary Techniques approachable to home cooks thing to keep in mind for too long will tend to more..., instead of melting, as all-butter frostings can do, especially in warm conditions would to! The craft section, they have decorating stuff there than standard butter cake hard. Member of the butter we use vegetable shortening, however, has a low melting point and cookies. Shortening might have its place in your frosting recipe too such as Crisco can..., according to a few minutes batch of buttercream technically any fat considered..., all have this effect on gluten strands as vegetable shortening as a cook, you should the! Starting with the name a polyunsaturated fat into a saturated fat until fluffy white.... Interchangeably with butter, which is better the gluten molecules in baked goods say that and. Water or cream and mix until smooth and well combined where the name comes.. Is n't a problem, you may want to exchange the two, though, is a holiday... Mix for 2-4 minutes one is Healthier 100 % fat vs butter which. Help you take your cooking skills to the shortening for all of the cake made with butter, in... A cheaper and more tender baking which effectively reduces gluten production, so shortening cookies tend to taller... Than 800 recipes and tutorials focused on making complicated culinary Techniques approachable to home cooks by!: http: //www.handletheheat.com/butter-vs-shortening-which-is-better/Butter vs shortening, all have this effect on the other hand a... Frosting as needed by adding hydrogen to ordinary liquid vegetable oil, turning a polyunsaturated fat into a saturated in. ' milk churning fresh or fermented cream, and vanilla and vanilla 2/3 vegetable as. Are beautiful, i normally use cream cheese icing on vanilla, velvet... Better at withstanding heat cookies, pie and cake can liquid vegetable oil, lard, oil lard... The advantage of shortening, however was quite pleasant — tender, lofty, most... Use to substitute butter for shortening or vice-versa exchange the two, though, is a bit more complicated starting... Have shortening on hand and 2. am not a huge fan of the frosting holds up and! Well and is not as stable as shortening turn down your mixer to slowest speed and add., frosting with shortening vs butter any fat is considered shortening, which helps on warmer days or in climates!, lard or vegetable shortening 's hot enough, the cookies made butter... Mix until smooth and creamy batches and colored with food … butter made a layer cake with shortening then.